Since it's the first day of October, I thought it would be fitting if we started to discuss Halloween (hey, stores are already clearancing Halloween stuff to make room for Christmas trees so I should get some sort of prize for waiting this long!).
Pinky's First Halloween, 2006 - a pink butterfly
Pinky 2007 - Cheer Bear Care Bear
Pinky 2008 - Purple Unicorn
Chaos' First Halloween, 2008 - a fireman